Shaker Lemon Pie

© Warren_Price via Canva.com

Jump to Recipe

Quick Bite

Shaker lemon pie is a bright, tart pie made with whole thin-sliced lemons, sugar, eggs, and a flaky crust. It is sweet, sharp, old-fashioned, and very serious about wasting absolutely none of the lemon.

History

Shaker lemon pie, also called Ohio lemon pie, is tied to the Shaker communities that lived in Ohio and other parts of the Midwest and Northeast. The Shakers were known for simplicity, order, craftsmanship, and a practical “waste nothing” approach to daily life.

That philosophy shows up clearly in the pie. Instead of using only lemon juice or zest, Shaker lemon pie uses the whole lemon, peel, pith, and pulp, with the seeds removed. The lemons are sliced paper-thin and macerated with sugar until softened before being mixed with eggs and baked.

Because the whole lemon is used, the pie has a marmalade-like texture and a bold sweet-tart flavor. It is not a mild lemon cream pie. It has edge, brightness, and a little bitterness from the peel and pith.

The pie remains a beautiful example of how a small number of ingredients can become something memorable. Lemons, sugar, eggs, and crust, that is basically it. The trick is patience and thin slicing.

Fun Facts

• Shaker lemon pie uses the whole lemon except the seeds.
• It is also known as Ohio lemon pie.
• The lemons need to macerate in sugar for hours so the peel softens.

Where to Try

Make it at home from a traditional-style recipe Ohio heritage baking
This is the best way to experience the pie’s whole-lemon texture and bold flavor.

Ohio heritage events and Shaker history sites Ohio
Look for it around Shaker-related programming, historical food events, or regional baking demonstrations.

Local Ohio bakeries by special order Ohio
Some pie shops and bakeries may make Shaker lemon pie seasonally or by request, especially if they focus on heritage pies.

About the Game

This recipe is part of Van Life Challenge, a travel-themed board game from Gray Dog Games where players explore the United States, discover regional foods, and collect memorable experiences along the way.

Each featured food celebrates a real place, a local flavor, and the kind of delicious roadside discovery that makes every trip feel like an adventure.

Recipe

Print Recipe Cook Mode: OFF

Home-Cook-Friendly Shaker Lemon Pie Makes: 1 9-inch pie Prep: 25 minutes, plus macerating Cook: 45–55 minutes Difficulty: Medium Style: Ohio / Shaker Heritage Dessert

Ingredients

• 2 large thin-skinned lemons, such as Meyer if available
• 2 cups granulated sugar
• 4 large eggs
• ¼ teaspoon salt
• 2 tablespoons melted butter, optional
• 1 double pie crust
• 1 egg beaten with 1 tablespoon water, for brushing
• Coarse sugar, optional

Instructions

1. Wash the lemons: Wash the lemons very well.
2. Slice thin: Slice the lemons paper-thin, removing all seeds.
3. Macerate: Place lemon slices in a bowl with sugar.
4. Rest: Cover and let sit for at least 4 hours, preferably overnight, stirring occasionally.
5. Heat the oven: Heat the oven to 425°F.
6. Prepare the crust: Line a pie plate with the bottom crust.
7. Beat the eggs: Beat eggs with salt and melted butter if using.
8. Mix the filling: Stir the eggs into the lemon-sugar mixture.
9. Fill the pie: Pour into the pie crust.
10. Top the pie: Add the top crust, seal, and cut vents.
11. Finish the crust: Brush with egg wash and sprinkle with coarse sugar if desired.
12. Start baking hot: Bake for 15 minutes at 425°F.
13. Finish baking lower: Reduce heat to 350°F and bake for 30 to 40 minutes more, until golden and set.
14. Cool: Cool before slicing.

Traditional note: To make it more traditional, use whole lemons sliced as thinly as possible, macerate them in sugar overnight, and keep the filling simple with eggs and sugar. The pie should be tart, sweet, and a little marmalade-like.

www.vanlifechallenge
© 2026 Gray Dog Games